From 3D To 2D: The Reverse Evolution Of Mutant Mudds

By Ishaan . August 19, 2012 . 1:30pm

It’s always interesting to see how games change from their conception to the time that they’re shipped as a completed product. Take Mutant Mudds on the Nintendo eShop. It’s a retro-style 2D platformer that can be quite the challenge, but it wasn’t always this way. At one point, Mutant Mudds was a 3D platformer being developed for DSiWare, under the title Maximilian and the Rise of the Mutant Mudds.


Here’s what the transition from 3D to 2D was like:



Unfortunately, Renegade Kid were unable to find a publisher for Maximilian on DSiWare, and self-publishing the game wasn’t feasible at the time either, so they decided to shelve the project. Two years later, it re-emerged as a 2D platformer that looked nothing like the original, aside from featuring the same main character and the concept of using a water gun and jet pack.


“The way Mutant Mudds ended up being a 2D platformer was due to more of a whim than a calculated decision,” Renegade Kid co-founder, Jools Watsham, shared with Siliconera.


“We were developing a 2D platformer for XBLA, which had no connection to Mutant Mudds whatsoever, and due to the fact that I was in pixel-pushing mode the random thought to create a small pixel version of Max popped into my mind. What I drew at that moment is almost exactly what Max looks like today in Mutant Mudds.”


Now that Mutant Mudds is a relatively known entity, Renegade Kid are bringing it to the PC. The version PC will include all of the original eShop levels, as well as 20 new levels where you get to play as Max’s grandmom. The “Grannie” stages are tougher than the regular ones, but Grannie has the ability to use all power-ups at once, unlike Max. The PC version of the game also has online leaderboards and uses depth-of-field and blur effects to emulate the 3D effect seen in the 3DS version of the game.


Mutant Mudds will be released for PC on August 30th as a download game via GOG, Gamersgate, and Desura, as well as directly from Renegade Kid. For a week after release, you’ll be able to grab the game for $7.99, after which you’ll need to pay the regular price of $9.99.


Food for thought:


Renegade Kid have no intention of taking Mutant Mudds back to its original 3D concept any time soon.


“It’s certainly possible that we might explore a 3D platformer with Max in the starring role sometime in the future, but we do not have any plans to do so at this time,” says studio co-founder, Jools Watsham.


“I love 3D platformers—Mario Galaxy and Super Mario 3D Land being some of my favorites—but if I had to chose between a great 2D platformer or a great 3D platformer, I would choose to play a great 2D platformer every time. 2D offers a precise perception of the action, which 3D can not.”

Read more stories about & & on Siliconera.

  • Jonathan Keycross

    So while Ness was working on a game about gathering well-known heroes fighting a sub-space emissary from another world, Jeff worked on a game about fighting mudd…yup the industry surely is cruel sometimes…

    Still, the game looks very good. I wished they kept the 3D perspective, there aren´t that many 3D platformers compared to 2D ones. But I suppose they had their reasons for the change.

  • I think it is a good call.  I don’t know how far along that original version was but it doesn’t look nearly as compelling as the final product.  It also looked inspired by Mario Sunshine but if the combat is like shown in that video then controlling the water didn’t seem all as interesting.
    Maybe it is restraints of originally a DSi game…

  • the 3d screen on the 3ds solved this problem already, guys

    we can now have precise platforming in 3d

  • 9thsage

    I wish you’d asked….I’m kind of hoping we might get the levels from the PC version. I’d pay for a DLC pack of levels for Mutant Mudds on 3DS. :) The PC version isn’t bad by any means, I think I’d prefer to play the new levels on 3DS with their 3D and all that.

Video game stories from other sites on the web. These links leave Siliconera.

Siliconera Tests
Siliconera Videos