Nintendo Puzzle Collection

Can three classic puzzlers stand the test of time?


The Lowdown

Pros: Three puzzle games in one package, GBA support, same old games

Cons: You're paying for the same old games again, could have used a few extra games

Purchase at Play-Asia
Nintendo has a funny way of reusing its classic games. No game is too dated, too unpopular or even remade enough times to be resold again and again. Such is the case with the Gamecube's Nintendo Puzzle Collection. This package sports three classic puzzlers on one new package with some new graphics. The three games included are Dr. Mario, Yoshi's Cookie and Panel de Pon.

Let's go through the games in chronological order. The first is Dr. Mario, which made its debut on the NES and Game Boy in the 1990s. This game stars Mario who has some how gained medical certification to extinguish viruses. Mario has three types of viruses to take care of: the red ones, the blue ones and the yellow ones. The viruses can be eliminated by placing three of the same color pills in a row on top of a virus. Dr. Mario drops pills from the top of the screen and you have a limited amount of time to rotate and place the pieces on top of the viruses. If you clear all the viruses in the jar, you win the level. If you don't you lose and the viruses laugh at you, seriously they do. If this sounds  a lot like Tetris, you're right on. Dr. Mario originated in the time where everyone, including Nintendo, was trying to put a spin on Tetris. If you've played all of the old Dr. Mario's you'll notice that the graphics have been given a huge boost, an even larger boost than the Nintendo 64 version of Dr. Mario. You'll also notice the classic tunes, Fever and Chill are intact and sound a bit better than the NES versions. You'll also notice that Dr. Mario hasn't changed much in the last ten years and this game is pretty much the same Dr. Mario you've played before. Sure the graphics are better and there is one new song, but these novelties are superficial when you're actually engaged in the game.

Yoshi's Cookie, which was released in 1992, suffers similar problems to Dr. Mario. The gameplay, which was somewhat inventive ten years ago, has you rearrange stacks of cookies to place the pieces in a row. Most of the puzzles have solutions that allow you to beat a level in a few moves. The puzzles stay the same, which makes the game easier and easier. If you can't clear the cookies in one fell swoop more cookies will drop down allowing you more chances to clear the entire stack. Once the stack is gone you've won the level. Out of all of the games Yoshi's Cookie has the most cosmetic additions. There are cute animations in the menu of Yoshi chasing Mario and Mario posting a banner that says push start. However, during the game the improved graphics go pretty much unnoticed. There are some new sound bytes of Mario saying muffled GBA like cheers. Besides that this game is the same old Yoshi's Cookie as before. Out of all of the games Yoshi's Cookie is easily the most boring. Puzzle games thrive from some amount of randomness. This forces players to be quick on their feet and think. Since Yoshi's Cookie deals the same puzzles over and over again the game focuses on memorization of a solution. Another problem with this style is that if you lose say level 3-3 you need to play all of the puzzles to get to 3-3 over again. Which means you'll be getting sick of level 1-1 really quickly.

Most US gamers probably never heard of Panel de Pon since it was released in Japan only. Which is kind of ironic since, Panel de Pon is the most improved and arguably the most entertaining game in the package.  Panel de Pon places you in a sea of blocks that move upwards. You can switch any two blocks by selecting them and pushing the A button. Your goal is to use the ability to switch blocks to make rows of three or greater, so you can clear the rising stack of colored blocks. If you clear four or more blocks the column briefly freezes, allowing time for you to think of your next move or position blocks for a combo. What makes this game so much fun is the intensity the game reaches at higher levels. You can see the column rising faster and faster, while you're moving random blocks around hoping something will clear. Panel de Pon contains the original 2D mode and also features an all new 3D mode. The 3D mode has you rotating a short column of rising blocks rather than a wider column in the 2D mode. Both modes are equally fun to play and it is refreshing to see two different gameplay modes. The graphics in Panel de Pon are crisp and clear. They have a very "cute" look to them, there are cute little monsters running around on screen and blocks that smile when you clear them. With the addition of a whole new mode Panel de Pon is clearly the most refined game in this package.

The coolest addition to this package is its GBA support. If you own a GBA and a link cable you can download the SNES versions of these games into your GBA's flash ram. This means you can play Panel de Pon or Dr. Mario anywhere you want. The biggest problem with this whole package is that most gamers own these games for other systems. Repackaging these games with a face lift and selling them at the same price of brand spanking new title doesn't seem right. If you're a fan of puzzle games and haven't played these before (which is pretty unlikely, except for Panel de Pon) you'll love this collection. However, there are many more fresh games at the same price as this one, which makes it a tough recommendation.

Import Friendly?

The menus, for the most part are in English. You won't need any real instruction to learn how to play these games, since you've probably played them before. Even if you haven't these games have a simple learning curve, so you'll be able to pick up any of these games and play right away.

US Bound?

It is unlikely that this game will be released outside of the US due to a lack of interest in Japan.

Overall

If you have any other versions of these games this package is probably not worth getting. The main redeeming factors in the package is the addictive Panel de Pon and GBA support, but both of these aren't worth a full priced game.