When it comes to storytelling, it’s only natural to want things to wrap up with no loose ends. Indeed, there are virtual cottage industries out there dedicated to taking movies, comics, and games to task for leaving questions unanswered. It’s especially the case for stories that might appeal to children. In those cases very few difficult questions are ever asked and when they are, clear answers are typically provided. After all, if we’re trying to teach lessons then it’s probably best not to be too mysterious about it, right? Even media aimed at adults tends to take this approach if it’s seeking mainstream success.
Chiikawa: Something Small and Cute has become a massive success for its creator Nagano. It started off as little more than some amusing doodles posted on the artist’s X account but now has a successful anime, hit movie, and more merch than you can shake a stick at. The anime is now even being officially released in English on the official Chiikawa YouTube channel. As each new comic page was posted, a world started to take shape. Soon there were more characters, more details in the setting, and longer stories that spanned multiple pages.
Through several years’ worth of comic pages, we now know quite a lot about Chiikawa, their friends Hachiware and Usagi, various other denizens, and the magical yet occasionally dark world they all reside in. For as much as we’ve learned however, there are still many things we don’t know. Some things just happen for the amusement of the situation and probably aren’t meant to be taken too seriously. Why does whistle ramune candy sprout from nowhere sometimes? What’s up with that rice cooker embedded in the ground in the forest? Where does Kuri-Manju put all those calories?
Other mysteries might one day have the truth behind them revealed, but Nagano has them on a slow burn. What exactly happened between Momonga and Deka Tsuyo? Where does Usagi actually live? Why do some chiikawas become chimeras, and what does that really mean? What’s the deal with the armored Yoroi-sans? They’re all compelling things to think about, and every so often Nagano throws a little nugget of information out there to get the fans talking all over again.
Chiikawa also raises a lot of questions that are never going to be answered because it’s more interesting to let the fans consider them and make up their own minds. Indeed, one such question sits right at the center of this year’s number one hit movie in Japan, Chiikawa the Movie: The Secret of the Mermaid Island. It adapts one of the more complex comic arcs and the moral problem it puts forward is a big part of why the movie has become so successful. Its refusal to give the viewer relief with a clean answer to the problem resulted in something truly fascinating.
By leaving so much unexplained, Chiikawa allows the fans to try to fill in the gaps. It makes people think more about the world and its characters, and when it flirts with more challenging problems it generates some real discussion. Even younger kids enjoy talking about these mysteries. Perhaps more stories should be willing to leave those lingering questions and allow the audience to put in some work of its own.