Castlevania: Belmont’s Curse is the first Castlevania game since 2008. 18 years had to pass for a brand-new title in the series to come out. And no, I’m not counting Lords of Shadow. While I’m happy for those that enjoy the newest Castlevania romp, it’s not what I think about when I picture the series. If you were to ask me what defines a Castlevania game, I’d say it’s either the classic arcade-style original games, or the Koji Igarashi-led games. In the hypothetical sliding scale between Metroid and Castlevania, it seems like Belmont’s Curse veers closer to the former. In fact, I’d venture to say that there are too many Metroidvania games in the style of Metroid, and not nearly enough similar to the Igarashi-led Castlevania games.
When I think of Metroidvania in the Castlevania “Igavania” style, I think of games like Ender Lilies and Ender Magnolia, Team Ladybug’s Record of Lodoss War: Deedlit in Wonder Labyrinth and Blade Chimera, and of course, Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night. I’m sure there are a few more, but even so, the list isn’t very long. What differentiates these games different from the likes of Hollow Knight or Blasphemous is a heavier emphasis on RPG elements, varied weapons and equipment, different spells and abilities, and a design ethos more focused on fighting hordes of enemies, rather than focusing on moment-to-moment, deliberate and challenging enemy encounters.

By now it’s probably obvious that I gravitate towards the Castlevania side of things. However, I’ve officially run out of games in that style to play. I could boot up a plethora of other Metroidvania games, sure. But games that draw specifically from the style that originated with Castlevania: Symphony of the Night? I’m afraid it’s looking dire. And I get it. What I’m asking for is a fundamentally different design style from what’s popular in the genre nowadays. The Igavania games are, usually, experiences where the player has a lot more control over the pacing of enemy encounters. It’s pretty easy to cheese through a Symphony of the Night or Bloodstained, get a particular weapon drop and start mowing down enemies.
What’s more popular nowadays is the FromSoft style of challenge and curated fights. This style marries well with the non-linear exploration of the genre, but fundamentally changes how to approach combat and bosses, compared to how fast one can decimate bosses in Castlevania or adjacent games. Even the aforementioned Ender Lilies and Ender Magnolia are skirting the line between Igavania and Soulslike at times. The same goes for a lot of other side-scrolling action games, like Salt and Sanctuary, The Last Faith, or Mandragora: Whispers of the Witch Tree. While these are interesting games, it’s not exactly what I’m looking for in this space either.

Recent gaming trends have drastically changed the Metroidvania, with games like Hollow Knight and Dark Souls influencing how the genre plays. Even Metroid Dread boasts a parry and an increase in challenge compared to the rest of the series. However, I’m glad that studios like Team Ladybug and ArtPlay are sticking to their guns, making approachable games in a style that I currently find so underrepresented.